Endings

Lies of P has three different endings available depending on the choices Geppetto's puppet makes throughout the game. After each ending players can either return to Hotel Krat for additional interactions with the NPCs there or proceed directly to New Game Plus.

Endings

Real Boy

The Real Boy ending is obtained by surrendering the P-Organ to Geppetto after defeating Simon Manus. Giving him the P-Organ will unlock this ending regardless of Humanity level. If Geppetto's puppet's Humanity is too low, this ending will happen automatically.

When Geppetto asks Geppetto's puppet to give up its heart, Geppetto's puppet complies, collapsing as Geppetto removes the heart and emplaces it into Carlo's body. This resurrects Carlo, who then massacres the survivors in Hotel Krat on Geppetto's orders. If Sophia was given peace, she will ask Carlo if this is the future he wanted. Geppetto replaces the survivors with puppet versions of themselves to act as Carlo's servants. Geppetto then departs, leaving Carlo with a letter revealing Geppetto will stabilize and rebuild Krat for Carlo and for Carlo to remain in the hotel.

Free From the Puppet String

The Free From the Puppet String ending is obtained by refusing to surrender the P-Organ to Geppetto while having low Humanity.

Geppetto's puppet refuses to give Geppetto its heart when asked. A disappointed Geppetto then opens up a case and brings out the Nameless Puppet in order to take Geppetto's puppet's heart by force. While fighting the Nameless Puppet, Geppetto's puppet loses its balance and falls to the floor. The Nameless Puppet then attempts to impale it but Geppetto steps in and takes the hit. Geppetto angrily asks the Nameless Puppet if it was going to destroy Geppetto's puppet's heart. Geppetto's puppet takes advantage of the distraction and kills the Nameless Puppet. Geppetto dies in Geppetto's puppet's arm while cursing it as a useless puppet. Geppetto's puppet returns to Hotel Krat where the survivors thank it for saving them and stopping the Alchemists.

Rise of P

The Rise of P ending is obtained by refusing to surrender the P-Organ to Geppetto while having high Humanity.

Plays identically to Free From the Puppet String until the Nameless Puppet is defeated. While dying, Geppetto notices that Geppetto's puppet is crying for him causing Geppetto to apologize before succumbing to his injury. Geppetto's puppet then wanders the Alchemist's base until it comes across a blue haired puppet. It transfers Sophia's ergo into the blue haired puppet, resurrecting her while Geppetto's puppet passes out shortly after. After awakening, Geppetto's puppet returns to Hotel Krat where the survivors thank it and Sophia leaves the Blue Butterfly's Letter on Geppetto's desk for it.